The Whistle Stop Cafe

I have been to the whistle stop many times, however my experience today has definitely ensured that I will not be returning. The service that I received was terrible, however the service given to an accessibility customer was disgusting. The customer, who utilized a wheelchair was refused a smaller container to take his leftovers because the waiter could not see the 'logic' behind it. I was served the wrong order & then overcharged. After leaving money the waiter yelled after us to pay.

Really good poutine! I recommend the pulled pork

Its okay, but not at night.

I love the whistle stop and I've went several times, however, as of late I had only one problem. That problem is that late at night (specifically tonight) I was given a so-so Poutine that lacks in comparison to those served by the staff during the day. While mostly, my poutine has very crisp fries, tonnes of gravy, and cheese melting underneath - this one did not. I am mainly going to place that fault on whoever was there, I usually tip but not tonight. I know its not the regular way the food is, but I wish that there were more people at night to make sure the food is made properly and up to the everyday standards they have. So, all in all, GREAT Poutine but not at night - won't be going there at all unless its during the day!

Great, but needs Improvement

Ive gone to Whistlestop quite a few times, but most of the time me and a couple of friends just go to the Poutine bar. Its one of our favourite parts of the restaurant, but if it were just a little better than I'm sure it would be the best food in downtown Peterborough. The problem with their poutine is that they don't use hand-cut fries and also use processed cheese. Although it's pretty bad for you and is overpriced (although you do get a lot) it's really delicious. Their sandwhiches, chips, and hotdogs are good as well, but not very high quality. It's fine, and you'll get some good stuff with some of the cheaper dishes, but it needs improvement to be good, and if they did improve I wouldn't mind paying a little more. The atmosphere is not the main attraction here. It's a very ordinary room. There is some Native art on the walls but it isn't very attractive and the lounge in the corner looks like it was scrapped together with furniture people donated because they were broken in some way. I like going to Whistlestop, and I will keep going there, but ultimately improving on their atmosphere and the quality of their food just a little bit would drastically improve their score. Go there, just don't expect way too much from them.

We went because we heard of the poutine bar. The poutine wasn't anything exciting. The fries weren't cooked properly, they weren't homemade, the gravy was probably canned and the cheese didn't seem like real curds (shredded cheese....) The prices were surprising, a little high for a poutine. And when you look around they've got old furniture, ripped couches and dust everywhere above the prep area behind the counter...not overly attractive. The other thing that struck me as weird were the sizes, only 2 options, small and HUGE, nothing in the middle. I think this place has huge potential to be much better, just needs a good clean and some better cooking methods.